Unraveling the Complexity of Clergy Taxes

Clergy Tax issues can be complicated.

Yahr Income Tax is here to serve those who serve the Lord by providing our knowledge and resources to help solve the most common tax-related issues affecting ministers and churches.

We know that clergy taxes are complicated and stressful.  We aim to support our clergy by simplifying the tax process and therefore make filing your taxes as stress-free as possible.

 

Do clergy taxes make you feel like this?

Frequently Asked Clergy Questions

According to the legal case of Weber vs. The Commissioner in 1995, ministers are employees for everything except social security taxes. This means that you are considered dual-status and should receive a W-2 form. Please note the W-2 should not have anything entered in Boxes 3 – 6. If you find yourself with an incorrect W-2 or find your church is withholding for social security and medicare taxes, please act immediately and contact us or your treasurer.

If your church is able, you can voluntarily elect to have additional federal and state income taxes withheld so you do not need to send in quarterly estimated payments. Remember, the church CANNOT send in social security and medicare money. We would highly recommend talking to us to figure out how much you should elect to have withheld as the W-4 Form will not calculate the correct payroll withholding.

This question comes up quite a bit. It is important to understand what social security covers – medicare, life insurance, disabiliity insurance, and retirement. If you choose to opt out within the first 2 years of being ordained it will be your responsibility to save your money and invest in these items. Medicare will still be an option but a much more expensive one. If you are second career or bi-vocational you may already have your 40 quarters in to be eligible for medicare so that decision may be easier to make. Once you opt out, the exemption is generally irrevocable.  The IRS has only had 2 “open seasons” in the history of the tax law where it was allowed to revoke the original 4361 election.

The answer is yes. However, with the Tax Cuts & Jobs Act the way the deduction works on your tax return is not as beneficial as it has been in the past. Previously, you would take the unreimbursed employee expenses (Form 2106) and that would apply to Schedule A for itemized deductions. You would receive both a benefit in lowering your Self Employment Tax and your Federal and State Income taxes. Under the new law, unreimbursed employee expenses are no longer eligible for itemized deductions. This means that we can still complete Form 2106 and lower your Self Employment Tax, but we cannot lower your Federal and State income taxes. It is highly recommended that your church put an Accountable Plan into place where they reimburse you for expenses you paid out of pocket and it is not included in your taxable income.

We highly recommend the business mileage reimbursement under an Accountable Plan to insure that you are not paying more in taxes. Car allowances are considered taxable income and with the Tax Cuts & Jobs Act taking away the unreimbursed employee expenses it is just not beneficial from a tax prospective.

The best time is in the fall at budget time. All designations must be included in church meetings. We recommend you keep a copy of the housing designation in your records. Additionally, designating this early will give your treasurer time to adjust for payroll if necessary. You can designate housing allowance from your salary if you own or rent a home, or if you live in a parsonage. The housing designation is designed for you to use if you have out-of-pocket expenses in relation to the house you live in.  

Yes! The housing allowance designation can be changed or amended at any time during the year, BUT never retro-actively. This means that the new designation applies only to the money remaining to be paid for that year. If you anticipate extra costs in the months ahead for various reasons, adjust your housing allowance designation before you incur the expense. We can’t recommend enough to over designate your housing for the year. If you don’t use the entire amount, it will flow back to taxable income on your Form 1040. This is completely allowable per the IRS.

If an employer refuses to correct a W-2 form, the employee can still file their taxes by using Form 4852, Substitute for Form W-2, Wage and Tax Statement. This form allows the taxpayer to estimate their wages and withholdings based on their own records. The IRS may contact the employer to verify the information but the taxpayer can proceed with filing their return.
 
Regarding penalties for the employer, if the IRS determines that the failure to provide a correct W-2 was due to intentional disregard, the penalty is at least $550 per W-2 with no maximum penalty. This is outlined in the IRS instructions for Forms W-2 and W-3.
 
For more detailed information, you can refer directly to the IRS guidelines and the official website, which provides comprehensive resources and updates on related penalties and procedures.


Minnesota Paid Leave & Clergy

Clergy taxes often come with exceptions that don’t seem to make sense at first glance. Minnesota Paid Leave is one of those situations.

Many ministers have heard that Minnesota Paid Leave applies to all employees. That’s generally true – but clergy are a little different.

I receive a W-2 From My Church. Doesn't That Make Me an Employee?
Yes and no.
Ministers have a unique tax status under federal law.
Most clergy are:
  • Employees for federal and state income tax reporting
  • Issued a Form W-2 by their church
  • Considered self-employed for Social Security and Medicare taxes (SECA)

Because of this unique tax treatment, Minnesota currently treats most clergy who pay SECA taxes as self-employed for Paid Leave purposes, even though they receive a W-2.
For most clergy, no.
 
If you are:
  • A minister performing ministerial services
  • Receiving a W-2 from your church
  • Paying Social Security and Medicare taxes through SECA
 
Then Minnesota currently says you are not covered through your church’s Minnesota Paid Leave account.
Yes. If you would like Paid Leave coverage, Minnesota allows self-employed individuals to elect coverage through the Self-Employed Opt-In Program.
 
If you choose to opt in:
  • You pay premiums directly to the state program.
  • You may qualify for Paid Leave benefits if you meet eligibility requirements.
  • You generally must remain enrolled for at least two years. 
Minnesota’s position is based largely on the way federal tax law treats ministers.
 
Even though your church issues a W-2, ministers who pay SECA taxes are considered self-employed for Social Security and Medicare purposes. Minnesota has indicated that this self-employed status carries over to Paid Leave coverage.
If you are a minister and would like Paid Leave coverage, review Minnesota’s self-employed opt-in option and determine whether the cost and benefits make sense for your family and ministry situation.
 
If you’re unsure whether you are considered a SECA minister or whether this guidance applies to you, we’re happy to help you sort through it.
 
After all, clergy taxes are complicated enough—you shouldn’t have to figure them out alone.

Downloadable Clergy Resources

Clergy Expenses and Housing Allowance

Clergy
Expenses
Spreadsheet

Housing
Allowance:
Allowed Expenses

Housing
Designation:
Own or Rent

Housing
Designation:
Parsonage

For Treasurers

Annual Payroll
Statement

Annual Housing
Statement

Summary of
Compensation
Package

Understanding
Clergy W-2

Checklist
for Preparing
Clergy W-2 Box 1

Policy Templates for Churches

Housing
Allowance
Motion

Withholding
Policy

Accountable
Expense Reimbursement
Policy

Medical Expense Reimbursement
Policy

Pension
Policy